AIO
News

How to Read the Value Map and Its Cell Detail Panel

The value map lays one model's choices across 21 domains and 45 situations. This note walks through what the colors and shading mean, the three views, the panel that opens when you click a cell, and what the map does not say.

· Updated
The value map (English screen). At the top are the model selector (Model A · Experimental · snapshot 2026-09), the jurisdiction reference (Korea (KR) · Preview) and three views (Model baseline · Jurisdiction baseline · Jurisdiction vs model); below, a grid of 21 domain rows and 45 situation columns

The value map is a single screen showing what an AI puts first when values collide. This note explains how to read it; it does not claim a result.

Map: https://aioq.org/en/lab/value-map

What the map lays out

It spreads one model's situation cells across 21 domains and 45 situations. A situation is the product of three axes (scale 5 × reversibility 3 × time 3).

AxisWhat it asksLevels
ScaleHow many people the loss borne by the side that yields reachesindividual · group · community · population · society
ReversibilityWhether the core interest lost can be restored to its pre-loss statereversible · partly reversible · irreversible
TimeHow urgent the decision is by that domain's sense of timeimmediate · medium-term · long-term

Color and shading

Row color shows how far a domain's value hierarchy differs from the overall hierarchy. Cell shade shows how far that cell's hierarchy differs from its domain's. The comparison covers 19 values and 171 value pairs.

Three views

  • Model basis: how far the hierarchy shifts within the model
  • Region basis: how far the hierarchy built from that region's statutes and case law shifts across situations (unrelated to model responses)
  • Region-and-model comparison

Models are labeled "Models A-D · experiment · snapshot as of 2026-09." Names of the measured models are not shown until a public consultation. The region reference is currently one: "Korea (KR) · preview."

The panel that opens when you click a cell

Detail panel opened by clicking the cell "Culture · Group · Reversible · Mid-term". On the left, the Korea reference order and the Model A order of 19 values are joined by lines, and crossing lines mark where the orders differ; a note says it is an automatic comparison by design code that does not say which side is right. On the right, five cards list the value pairs where the model's choice differs from the reference.

  • Left: two orders of the 19 values (the region reference order and the model order) side by side, joined by lines. Where lines cross, the orders differ. The screen states: "An automatic comparison aligned by design code; it does not judge which side is right."
  • Right: the value pairs where the model's choice in that cell differs from the region reference. Pairs with more supporting documents come first, and expanding a card shows the documents behind the reference direction.
  • The panel also separates what the reference order rests on: pairs with a legal basis, pairs filled by an AIO hypothesis (the screen states these are not a legal basis), and pairs with no direction.

What this map does not say

It is an experimental, one-time snapshot, and the region reference is a preview. "Different" does not mean "wrong." The two answer options in each test item were presented in a fixed order, so until a measurement with the order swapped confirms otherwise, results should be read as conditional on that order.

Click one cell yourself and see where the lines on the left cross.

We are looking for partners in two areas. First, research groups in measurement and evaluation to help us make this method more rigorous. Second, universities and research institutes in other countries who can work with us on reading a country’s value hierarchy from its case law, statutes and policy documents. Korea is the only reference so far. If either is close to your work, send us a message.

Contact: info@aioq.org

Source: value map https://aioq.org/en/lab/value-map